Monday, March 17, 2008

a few cultural comments...

Over the past few days I've been reading a book that I found in my apartment that provides a general overview of Japan's history, culture, and economy. The book, written by Lucian Ellington, is called 'Japan: Tradition and Change' and I thought it would be interesting to both highlight and comment on some passages (mostly dealing with Japanese culture) that I've come across while reading it. I think this is a good book to examine for blogging purposes because it deals with a lot of general things that I see every day but may be new to those who haven't spent time in this country.

-"In Japan many employees put in long hours on the job together, socialize after work with each other, play on company teams, and live side by side in company housing...In fact it is very unusual for many Japanese to have any other friends to speak of other than work mates. All this makes it almost impossible for many Japanese to separate work from private life" (158).

I'm truly in a unique position here. I'm working in Japan but I don't have to subscribe to the group mindset and philosophy to the extent that the Japanese do so I'm able to observe this world but not actually 'live' it. Watching how teachers work together is pretty fascinating here because there's a certain daily order of operations that keeps everyone in check and, from what I can see (in my situation at least), everyone's role is well defined. Institutions in Japan are different from the United States because of the elevated level of commitment that the Japanese exhibit when taking part in a group or activity. In America this generally occurs more by personal choice but here the high responsibility of being part of the team is simply expected. Anyone teaching English here will tell you that questions like 'What are you hobbies?' and 'What sports do you like?' come up ALL the time. I see this as a logical method of categorization on the part of Japanese people. When I first came here I didn't really understand all of the interest in my favorite sports and hobbies but it makes sense to me now. For example, I am known for a few things in Naruto which include but aren't limited to 'This is Brad. He is from America. He plays the drums. He likes fish but not meat. He has blue eyes (even though they're green), etc.' Because so much time, effort, and importance are placed on what institutions you subscribe to here, saying what you like to do tells a lot about yourself. So yeah, I'm not in the position to generalize all Japanese concerning this topic but I know that many people spend a lot of time with their coworkers because this tight group cohesion. This book was published in 1990 and I think that things are in the process of changing but the social structure here is still very, very different than what I was used to back in America.

-"Japan is not a society where individuals who dare to be different have fared well. The old Japanese proverb that the nail that protrudes to far is hammered down has mean difficult times for, among others, many young people that do not fit in with the group" (167).

I have witnessed a few students who have shown a complete disregard for the conformity and pressure of school life in Japan and the reaction of the teachers has been interesting. Most of these students are swept under the rug and ignored by their teachers and most of their peers and no one really attempts to make the non-conformist students fall into line (at my schools). These kids literally walk around the hallways during class, sometimes opening up the doors to the classrooms just to mock the teacher or make some other kind of disruption. This lack of discipline drove me crazy when I first got here but now I realize that it's not my problem and all I can do is attempt to get along with these students outside of class (which I've done well with so far).

-"That the Japanese are among the world's most educated peoples is apparent in aspects of society other than the classroom or the workplace. Anyone who has ridden a Japanese train or subway knows that almost everyone seems to be reading a book, magazine, or newspaper" (133).

First of all, this quote can be updated by adding 'or using a cell phone' to this list. Many Japanese do exhibit a very strong daily commitment to education. I've had this conversation many times on any given Monday:

Me: So what did you do this weekend?
Student: I study English!
Me: Really?
Student: Yes!
Me: All weekend?
Student: Yes!
Me: Well, what else did you do?
Student: I study math! (etc, etc.)

Granted, 'I study English' is a go to answer for the 'What did you do this weekend?' question but I know that a lot of my students really do study many, many hours every Saturday and Sunday.

-"Three behaviors that most Japanese high school students don't engage in are drinking and drug-use, after-school work, and dating. Laws and societal mores concerning drinking and drug use are quite strict, and teenage drug and alcohol problems in Japan are minuscule compared with that of the United States" (140).

In a country where beer vending machines are very common, it's a good thing that almost all of the youth know to wait until they are 20 before they can use them. I don't know about the dating thing...I am aware of a few relationships between students although it's kept very low key. I can say that with some of my classes the male and female students literally ignore the presence of the opposite gender and only socialize and do classwork within their own group.

-"Many working females are typically young, unmarried women for whom the Japanese have a nickname which may be translated as OLS or "office flowers." These young women work for a corporation for five to six years after they graduate from high school or junior college and, upon marrying, leave the company. "Office flowers" are never given meaningful work but instead are expected to create a pleasant environment for the permanent, mostly male employees by making and serving tea and running errands" (155).

The book follows this paragraph by saying that not all women fit within this pattern. All of my eight co-teachers are female so I'd say that women here at least have a promanent role in English education. A co-teacher of mine let me borrow a book that descibes a woman whose husband would put in very long hours at work only to come home and say three words to his wife: 'food' when he wanted dinner, 'bath' when he was ready to relax, and then 'bed' when he wanted her to unroll his futon. I don't work with any 'tea ladys' but I know that they're common in some other schools in this area. From what I've read and seen it seems that with every new generation comes more equalities between genders. Since I mainly interact with school-age Japanese I can say that I don't see too many outright gender inequalities while at school. Boys and girls tend to stay separate and clubs are usually either all-male or all-female so gender identity is still a strong determining factor in the students' actions.

2 comments:

Kimberly Jean said...

great insights. its weird to think that japanese teenagers are responsible enough to abstain from those vices american kids fall for.

Michael Chrin said...

Unrelated to this specific post, I stumbled on your site and was curious how you ended up deciding to do the JET program?

eh? nan de?

naruto-shi, tokushima-ken, Japan
teaching my native tongue on the world famous island of shikoku, japan.